Things to consider
Scenario 2: Generative AI can be used only in a particular way
If it is determined that generative AI use is permitted in particular ways for a piece of assessment, then colleagues should ensure that they provide clear instruction to students in advance of the course beginning, so that students understand what they can and cannot do.
Further Context of Scenario 2
Extent to which AI is permitted
- Students are permitted and supported to use GenAI with restrictions in place as outlined by the course coordinators. This category applies to most assessments and guidance about use of GenAI (which tasks and how to use it) needs to be made in assessment briefs.
- Broad sub-categories of permitted GenAI use may be applicable, such as:
- Drafting – using GenAI not as content generator, but as idea development and guidance on structure, process or style.
- – using GenAI not as content generator, but as proof-reader, writing assistant and to get feedback on own work. Specify whether rewriting is allowed or not, which might depend on the context of the assessment.
- Co-creating – GenAI may be used to generate content and other assistive tasks, but warning should be headed that the student is expected to verify all content and be rigorous in ensuring the quality of the work. GenAI tools should not be regarded as co-authors because authorship requires human qualities such as accountability for content and making a declaration of originality.
- Learning assistant – GenAI may be used during the learning process to help clarify concepts or speed up processes where the process is not part of the assessment.
Quality assurance considerations
- In all cases where GenAI is used, students should be instructed to acknowledge that use. Clear instruction should be provided on how to do this, e.g. via Acknowledgement section, Declaration, or Reference list.
- is expected that this category of GenAI adoption should set out very clearly expectations of how GenAI ‘may’ and ‘should not’ be used along with a brief statement on why it is restricted and permitted in specific circumstances. The ‘may be used’ list serves to indicate support available to maximise learning opportunities, whereas the ‘should not be used’ list serve to uphold academic integrity, avoid overreliance on GenAI or outline good practice. A complete list may not be possible but will help guide students in understanding what is acceptable in that context and develop awareness of what constitutes good
Implications for assessment and design
- In determining that some GenAI usage is permissible, staff must consider before finalising the assessment design, how they wish their students to use or engage with the tools. Avoid partial use of GenAI unless you are very clear how you would know if GenAI had been used in ways other than those permitted. Assessment design is crucial.
- Teaching staff need to carefully think about what ‘evidence’ is needed to demonstrate learning as a process rather than solely as an end product that is assessed. In order to undertake this approach staff should draw upon the principles of the Learning Through Assessment Framework.
Example Statement that could be included in assessment brief
In this assessment, you are allowed to use GenAI tools in some specific ways as part of your assessment. The use of GenAI tools can augment specific parts of your submission; these are clearly detailed below. You must not use GenAI tools outside of the scope permitted below. [Staff detail the specific instructions on the use of GenAI tools. Remember not to mention specific tools by name, but instead provide guidance on how the student might use a category/type of GenAI tool, how the student should reference or acknowledge use of the tools, and why the restrictions are in place.] If using any form of GenAI tool, you must acknowledge how the tools have been used within your work as per the instructions from your course co-ordinator. You cannot submit any content produced by GenAI as your own work. |
Teaching and assessing data skills in the age of GenAI
Thu, 10 Oct 2024 16:48:00 BST
Strategies for students to report GenAI contributions in assessments
Thu, 10 Oct 2024 16:50:00 BST
Examples of using GenAI to complement in-text feedback comments
Thu, 10 Oct 2024 16:52:00 BST
Using GenAI to generate exemplars for teaching
Fri, 11 Oct 2024 09:10:00 BST
Generative AI for Study Skills – an active learning approach
Fri, 11 Oct 2024 09:14:00 BST
Scientific writing: Encouraging students to participate in the process in addition to output
Fri, 11 Oct 2024 09:19:00 BST